It has generally been accepted that the ecumenical creeds as we have them today, are mainly responses to the issues that were debated when they were written. In as much as creeds have nourished faith and undergirded ecclesial worship for centuries, however, they may not deeply present all the most important things that we should believe in. In the African soil, the ecumenical creeds have with time been reduced to idle spaces in liturgical expressions and with many denominations skipping them or glossing over them during worship altogether. The crafting of the famous Maasai creed was an attempt at enculturating faith by expressing an African desire for tangible realties of faith rather than abstract issues of doctrine. It is probably to date one of the greatest credo attempts at resisting the ecumenical creeds in their current representation by mirroring Christian belief through the cultural eyes. However, in the abundance of its strengths, the Maasai creed is not without its good share of cultural, ecclesial and theological deficiencies. While appreciating the task of the Maasai creed, this paper offers a critique of the creed through a cultural, ecclesial and theological lenses and proposes ways in which is can be revamped to reinvigorate desire for a more centralized space for creeds in contemporary African liturgical and Christian faith practices.